21 January, 2021

Rights Diary

Journalist Makepeace Sitlhou asks when it comes to the North East, whose rights is it anyway?

Illustration by Saahil
Rights Diary
Act of Desperation

Days before the nationwide COVID-19 lockdown was announced, I was sitting in the living room of a young businessman in Assam’s Dibrugarh district. He and his friend, both in their twenties, had just been released from the central jail, having spent more than two months in jail for participating in the mass agitation in Assam’s Brahmaputra valley against the contentious Citizenship Amendment Act (CAA).

The new law is seen as a massive betrayal by the natives of Assam. More so given the fact that they had enthusiastically voted the BJP to power in the state for the first time, on the premise that the party will finally resolve the issue of illegal migration that has been festering for decades.

Though the mass protests appeared to unite all those opposed to CAA, the cracks were visible. While still opposed to the infiltration of ‘illegal’ immigrants to their land, time in detention had broken the spirits of the two men. “We’re not a part of the Krishak Mukti Sangram Samiti (the organisation that led the protests in upper Assam) but since the police detained us, they should have bailed us out, too. Instead they were only helping to release their members,” one of them said.

The two were among the thousand-odd protestors who were detained in December 2019 by police. With the time spent away from family and their names on police record, the two no longer hold any faith in the mass movement in Assam. More than 400 kilometers away in Guwahati Central jail, KMSS leader Akhil Gogoi—often accused by the authorities of pursuing a Maoist agenda—and three of his associates were locked away under the Unlawful Activities Prevention Act, charged with sedition and other penal acts. A repressive law that allows detention up to six months without a trial or charges being framed, the UAPA has become the tool of choice among the national security laws to curb dissent. Gogoi continues to be in jail.

Year of the Lockdown

By April, we were caught in the midst of the lockdown and life came to a halt in the otherwise bustling city of Guwahati. The virus took over our lives and the minute updates of a rapidly developing situation kept us hooked to our smartphones. While I took to Netflix and Audible to escape the dystopia around us, many in my home state of Manipur were struggling to receive the rations they were promised.

Naturally, they took their angst out on social media— most of them were just pure concerns and curious questions—leading to their arrest or being booked under the National Disaster Management Act, 2005. At least 13 cases of detention, arrests and FIRs were recorded in the month of April, alone. In all likelihood, I, too, would have been booked for reporting this story had I been with my parents in Churachandpur district.

At a time when the state most needed a stable government, ministers were playing turncoats and switching parties in the middle of a pandemic. Manipur’s civil society, which had long been at the forefront of the civil liberties movement in the valley, found itself to be mostly mum on the slew of arrests trampling free speech. Journalist Kishorchandra Wangkhem, who had already spent a year in detention under the NSA after charges of sedition filed against him failed, was once again booked under sedition. He was, however, freed recently.

This time, too, it was over a post on Facebook, where he cheekily took a dig at a local minister’s second wife that landed him in jail in October. He was also booked under the SC/ST Act since the first wife belongs to the Maram tribe. Wangkhem’s wife Ranjita said that her husband’s post was to “admonish the non-tribal woman for airing a derogatory comment about a tribal woman and causing communal disharmony”. The second wife, who had originally posted the alleged comment about the minister’s tribal wife, however, did  not face any police action.

Perils of Native Nationalism

We entered the year shouting slogans to protect our land, culture and language from any kind of domination pushed by the Centre’s interests and designs. But as the year progressed, I have seen the region only devolve to new lows of nativist nationalism, spawning public harassment and violence of the kind that we are victims to in the mainland. While we faced ethnic slurs in the cities and racial discrimination on the long journey back during the lockdown, back home communities were pitted against each other over state boundaries and the old issue of “encroachment”.

In a fitting finish to a year of hostilities, the North East Students’ Organisation has demanded the government to carry out a National Register of Citizens (NRC) exercise in all the states in the Northeast. Mind you, they have not demanded improved healthcare system, proper healthcare assessment for the hundreds of families affected by the Baghjan gas well blowout or legal aid for all those prosecuted for peaceful protests or free speech.

I guess now is a good time to ask as any—whose rights is it anyway?

Makepeace Sitlhou is an award-winning journalist based in Guwahati
Latest Magazine

January 25, 2021

other articles from the issue

articles from the previous issue

Other magazine section