17 April, 2021

Mughlai Paranthas

The secularist lens may project a selective view of medieval history, but facts speak otherwise

Mughlai Paranthas
How did relations between Hindus and Muslims evolve over the centuries following Mohammad bin Qasim’s invasion of Sind in 711 AD? Did the invaders have just imperial motives? Were they interested only in India’s phenomenal wealth, and not in bringing the vanquished under the flag of Islam by sword? These are questions that are important for understanding what led to the creation of Pakistan, and the complex relationship between Hindus and Muslims in the subcontinent.

The Hindu-Muslim relationship is a complicated one, with interwoven layers of cooperation and confrontation. The secularists, which include communists of various hues, have repeatedly tried to simplify the phenomenon. In the process, the communists supported Jinnah’s demand for a theocratic Pakistan and have twisted history by selectively picking incidents and details to paint a rosy picture of Hindu-Muslim relations before the advent of the British.

Beyond Turk and Hindu—a set of 13 essays in three sections—is one more such attempt. The essays exhume copious references of amicable...

In this article:

More from Balbir K. Punj

Latest Magazine

April 26, 2021

other articles from the issue

articles from the previous issue

Other magazine section